Scroll to top
© 2020, Norebro theme by Colabrio

Challenges of Third-Party Reproductive Donor Services for the Black Community


drtanyawilliams - February 12, 2024 - 7 comments

In the realm of third-party reproductive donor services, individuals and couples often face a myriad of challenges. For the Black community, these challenges can be particularly pronounced when seeking donor sperm and eggs to grow their families. This blog delves into the difficulties encountered by individuals like Natasha, as highlighted in Ben Carter’s piece from the BBC’s 2022 article called “Why can’t I find an Afro-Caribbean egg donor?”, as well as Amber Ferguson’s exploration of the Black sperm donor shortage in The Washington Post’s 2022 article called “America has a Black sperm donor shortage. Black women are paying the price.”

The Afro-Caribbean Egg Dilemma & Third-Party Reproductive Donor Services

Natasha’s journey, as shared by Ben Carter, sheds light on the scarcity of Afro-Caribbean egg donors. Faced with infertility issues, Natasha discovered that the dearth of donors from her ethnic background posed a significant obstacle. The statistics are stark – in 2017, only 15 out of 1,900 egg donors in the UK were categorized as “Black Caribbean,” despite this group constituting 1.1% of the population. Markedly, reproductive medicine specialist Dr. Edmond Edi-Osagie suggests a cultural reluctance among Afro-Caribbean women to donate eggs. As a result, this has led to a challenging situation for those in need.

The Silence and Stigma

One prominent issue, as Natasha points out, is the lack of awareness and discussion surrounding the shortage of Afro-Caribbean donors. The topic remains a taboo within the Black community, often mentioned in passing rather than addressed seriously. Furthermore, Helen George, a counselling psychotherapist, emphasizes the need for increased dialogue about infertility within the community and a more inclusive approach from the health system.

The Black Sperm Donor Shortage

Amber Ferguson’s piece highlights another facet of the challenge – the severe shortage of Black sperm donors. Despite a rising demand, Black men constitute fewer than 2 percent of sperm donors at major cryobanks. The reasons for this shortage are multifaceted, including the failure to recruit Black donors, stringent selection criteria, and historical mistrust of the medical profession within the Black community.

Competition and Difficult Choices in Third-Party Reproductive Donor Services

As a result, Black women seeking sperm donors often find themselves in fierce competition for a limited supply. Cryobank websites witness a rapid sell-out of vials from Black donors, leaving many women with difficult choices. Furthermore, the scarcity forces them to decide between selecting a donor of a different race, potentially raising a biracial child, or resorting to unregulated online platforms, as highlighted by Ferguson’s analysis.

The Complex Landscape of Sperm Donation

Moreover, the challenges extend beyond scarcity to the complex legal landscape surrounding sperm donation. The lack of regulation in private arrangements can lead to unforeseen complications, as illustrated by the legal battle faced by Maiya Skye and her wife, Shauntice. Furthermore, bypassing licensed cryobanks poses risks, emphasizing the importance of proper screening and legal safeguards in donor arrangements.

Evidently, the challenges faced by the Black community in third-party reproductive donor services are multifaceted and deeply rooted. From the scarcity of Afro-Caribbean egg donors to the shortage of Black sperm donors, individuals and couples encounter hurdles that necessitate broader awareness, open dialogue, and systemic changes. As Natasha advocates for increased awareness and Helen George urges for more inclusivity in infertility discussions, the hope is that these challenges will not only be acknowledged and addressed, but will additionally foster a more supportive environment for those seeking to build their families.

Resources:

NIH: Primary ovarian insufficiency: a glimpse into the racial and socioeconomic disparities found within third-party reproduction (2022)

The Bump: What to Know About the Lack of Diversity in Sperm and Egg Donors (2022)

The Washington Post: America has a Black sperm donor shortage. Black women are paying the price. (2022)

BBC: ‘Why can’t I find an Afro-Caribbean egg donor?’

Discover more related blogs from Dr. Tanya Williams Fertility Centre:

The Hidden Struggles of Black Women with Infertility: Three Women’s Stories

The Biggest Gaps in Women’s Health Research

Related posts